Jerusalem Letters of Lasting Interest
VP:113 15 Adar 5751 / 1 March 1991
A MEETING OF ANCIENT PEOPLES: WESTERN JEWS
AND THE DALAI LAMA OF TIBET
Nathan Katz
Searching Out the Jewish Secret for Surviving Exile / Hopes and
Apprehensions of the Jewish Delegation / Jews in Tibetan Eyes /
Explaining Judaism to Tibetan Buddhists / Meeting the Dalai Lama
/ Encounters with Teachers, Monks, Abbots, Nuns / "We are Both
Chosen People" / Confronting the Issue of Jews Who Become
Buddhists
[Editor's Note: As the world grows more interdependent, the
Jewish people and Judaism have begun to confront Asian, African
and American religions beyond Christianity and Islam, the
monotheistic faiths that grew out of the Jewish experience. This
encounter with the spiritual ideas of a world beyond Jewish
influences and the communities of that world raises new issues of
intergroup relations for Jews and new problems of relating to
other-than-monotheistic religious ideas, posing new questions for
Jewish theology and foreign policy. One such encounter has been
with Tibetan Buddhism and its spiritual leader, the Dalai Lama.
In the spirit of the Jerusalem Center's concern for the public
policy issues facing the Jewish people, we are pleased to bring a
first-hand account of the major encounter, to date, between the
two, written by one of the Jewish participants, Nathan Katz,
whose academic speciality has put him in a unique position in the
effort.]
Searching Out the Jewish Secret for Surviving Exile
Just prior to being awarded the Nobel Peace Prize in 1989, His
Holiness the XIVth Dalai Lama of Tibet briefly met with Jewish
leaders at a Buddhist monastery near New York City. As the
spiritual and temporal leader of a people who had been defeated
by Communist China thirty years ago, the world's preeminent
Buddhist monk wanted to learn the "Jewish secret" for surviving
exile. After all, he reasoned, the Jews had the expertise: 1,900
years of living in the diaspora, all the while preserving their
distinct religion. Surely the Tibetan people could benefit from
Jewish experience.
As a scholar of South Asian religions including Tibetan Buddhism,
and as a committed Jew, I was invited to join a delegation of
eight rabbis and scholars to meet with the Dalai Lama and Tibetan
leaders in Dharamsala, a hill station in the Himalayan foothills
of northern India, seat of the Tibetan government-in-exile. What
follows are excerpts from a diary of that historic meeting
between the Jewish and the Tibetan peoples.
October 18, 1990 - New York: Rabbi Zalman Schachter, the
charismatic Kabbalist from Philadelphia, has written a Hebrew
benediction especially for the occasion and he asks me to
translate it into Tibetan. He explains that there are
benedictions for meeting scholars and for meeting kings, but none
for meeting one who combined the two roles. So he composed:
"Blessed art Thou, L-rd Our G-d, King of the Universe, Who has
imparted of Thy compassionate awareness unto those who honor and
respect Thy Names."
October 21 - between Delhi and Chandigarh: In a four-car
convoy from Delhi to Dharamsala, I am riding with Zalman and
Rabbi Jonathan Omer-Man, founder of the School for Jewish
Meditation in Los Angeles. As the conversation turns to
theologies of exile, I relate an eight century Tibetan prophecy
about the destruction of Buddhism in Tibet and its
reestablishment in "the land of the red-faced people," taken to
refer to the Americas. According to the law of karma, all
actions in this world bear moral results, and many Tibetans
understand the loss of their homeland as a consequence of their
centuries of self-imposed isolation. When Tibet needed
diplomatic friends, she had none. Exile was made meaningful by
the fact that the loss of Tibet led directly to the spread of
Buddhism to Western countries. Do Tibetans also consider
themselves "a light unto the nations"?
Jonathan is intrigued by the Tibetan Buddhist meditational
practice known as "deity-yoga," wherein the practitioner
visualizes an aspect of divinity, and then proceeds to identify
with the mind-created deity. According to the Dalai Lama's sect,
this technique is the highest and most effective route to
enlightenment. Jonathan and Zalman speculate about the
anthropomorphism inherent in the exile idea of the exile of G-d's
presence, and they compare it with deity yoga.
We ponder the Dalai Lama's question about the "Jewish secret."
Was our survival due to our democratized emphasis upon education
as a goal for all Jews? Or the development of vernacular
languages such as Yiddish or Judesmo? Or the genius of the
rabbis
in developing halakhah? Or was it enforced from the outside
by
anti-Semitism and ghettoization? Most promising was the notion
suggested by author Rebbetzin Blu Greenberg of New York, that the
primacy of the home replaced the destroyed Temple in Jewish
observance, and thus made the religion more portable and
especially equipped the religion for survival in exile.
One idea was being overlooked, I offered, the belief that G-d's
providence ensured Jewish survival. Whether it was G-d or the
belief in G-d which sustained Judaism I could not say.
Zalman
said there are two ways to ask why in Hebrew: madua and
lamah,
the former looking for etiology, for origins, and the latter for
purpose, for teliology. Are we being asked how did we
survive,
or why did we survive? Understanding Jewish survival
required a
bifocal response, and interplay of causes and orientations.
October 22 - Dharamsala: Last night, as we neared the
Punjabi capital of Chandigarh, we were stopped at a military
roadblock. Local rioting had led to a strict curfew. In the
morning the road to Dharamsala is blocked by a student
demonstration, but we hire one of the student leaders to guide us
along back roads, bypassing the disturbances. We reach our
destination but wonder how we will get back to Delhi next week.
October 23 - Dharamsala: Our schedule, prepared by the Dalai
Lama's Council for Religious and Cultural Affairs, has us meeting
not only with the Dalai Lama and his senior advisors, but also
with abbots of the major monasteries, with government officials,
with youth leaders, and with Western students of Buddhism, many
of whom come from Jewish backgrounds.
Hopes and Apprehensions of the Jewish Delegation
Marc F. Lieberman, a San Francisco opthalmologist who organized
and raised funds for our delegation, asks each of us to share our
hopes and apprehensions about the upcoming dialogue. Blue hopes
to increase friendship for Israel; her apprehensions revolve
around Jewish law. In our unusual setting, a Tibetan refugee
community in India, is there danger of contravening halakhah?
Prior to our arrival, the kitchen at the Dalai Lama's guest house
had been scoured, burners lit, and cooking surfaces washed with
boiling water. New pots, pans, plates, utensils and cutlery were
purchased especially for us, and the food was to be strictly
vegetarian. She and Rabbi Yitz Greenberg, an Orthodox scholar
from New York, inspect the kitchen with me and are satisfied with
its kashrut. They are touched by the Tibetans' efforts.
Zalman hopes for further cooperation between the Tibetan and
Jewish peoples, and is especially encouraged that we will be in
direct contact with several echelons of Tibetan leadership.
Jonathan worries over the difficulty of discussing spirituality.
He confesses that in many ways he finds it easier to discuss
spirituality with Christians or Sufis than with fellow Jews.
Happily, by the end of the week he revises that view.
I voice my sense of the deep responsibility we carry as
emissaries of the Jewish people to the Tibetan people and that we
must find ways to institutionalize Tibetan-Jewish contacts. Any
number of Jews have studied Tibetan Buddhism, but there are no
Tibetans who have studied Judaism. As a start, we should try to
raise funds to enable two Tibetans to pursue Jewish studies at
the graduate level -- one at Hebrew University in Jerusalem and
one at my University of South Florida.
Professor Paul Mendes-Flohr of Hebrew University readily concurs
about the need for academic exchanges. As a self-proclaimed
secular Jew, he does not represent Jewish tradition but Jewish
modernity. Surely, no Jewish delegation could be complete
without this perspective.
Rabbi Joy Levitt, who leads a Reconstructionist synagogue on Long
Island, told her Sunday school children about this dialogue and
asked them to prepare messages for the Dalai Lama. She showed us
a notebook of touching letters and drawings with their heartfelt
advice. One nine-year-old concisely wrote: "We Jews have always
stuck together. No matter what. And if you Tibetans stick
together, you will get your country back too."
Dr. Moshe Waldoks, a Massachusetts writer and scholar who
participated in the 1989 dialogue, wonders whether this second
meeting can recapture the remarkable enthusiasm of the first.
Yitz, a regular participant in interreligious dialogues, wants to
help the Tibetans by raising Jewish awareness about their
persecution, motivating American Jews to champion their cause in
the U.S. Congress and at the United Nations. To date, no
American President has received the Dalai Lama, nor has he been
invited to address Congress. The United Nations has been as
silent about Tibet as it has been noisy about Israel.
The discussion turns to how to address the Dalai Lama. Most
Westerners call him "Your Holiness," but would that title imply
that he is divinity, an idea which would compromise an observant
Jew?
Jews in Tibetan Eyes
October 24: We are invited to attend the inaugural session of
the
Himalayan Conference on the Five Traditional Sciences, held at
the Dalai Lama's monastery, Thekchen Choling. In his remarks
before hundreds of Buddhist monks and scholars, the Dalai Lama
lavishly praises Jews for "their courage and great determination"
in preserving their religion and culture in the face of
tremendous obstacles and sufferings. He says that Tibetans
greatly admire Jews because "no matter how they are scattered
through all corners of the earth, they maintained their sense of
unity of the people," and he tells the audience how lucky they
are to have our delegation among them. His tremendous
compliment brings tears to Jewish eyes. One theme of the week
begins to emerge. By seeing ourselves reflected in the other, we
form an image of who we are. In Christian and Muslim cultures,
we Jews have seen in our reflections condescension if not
outright hostility. But in Tibetan eyes we see reflected
affection, respect and even a bit of awe. How differently one
knows oneself through such reflections.
Listening to the Dalai Lama talk about us, one gets the
impression that we Jews survived by an act of will. I wonder.
Was it determination and courage, was it persecution, was it G-d,
or was it belief in G-d which preserved Judaism? Is there a way
to translate into a Tibetan conceptual framework the idea of a
transcendent justification for empirical reality?
Explaining Judaism to Tibetan Buddhists
We have been invited to make a one-hour presentation about
Judaism to the Himalayan Conference, a unique opportunity to
speak before a distinguished group of Asian religious leaders.
We delegate the responsibility to Yitz, and he and I work
together on the format for his talk. I suggest the traditional
Tibetan way of analyzing a religion in terms of its view, its
path and its goal. Yitz likes the idea, and summarizes the
Jewish "view" as belief in a Creator Who endows creation with an
inherent sanctity. The Jewish "path" involves the study of
Torah, the performance of worship or ritual connections to the
transcendent, and acts of lovingkindness, our connections with
one another. The Jewish "goal" is wholeness, the world to come,
and the divine-human partnership in the repair of this world.
Tibetan Buddhism maintains transformation as a central metaphor,
in particular the transformation of the ordinary mind into the
enlightened mind, of defilement into wisdom. Judaism, too,
emphasizes transformation -- the human-divine partnership in
transforming this world into what it ought to be. Yitz's talk is
extremely well-received.
October 25th: Yitz and Zalman discuss what blessing to recite
upon the occasion of meeting with the Dalai Lama. Zalman wants
to use the new one he has composed for the occasion, but Yitz
hesitates. We should not go about composing new liturgy, he
cautions. Joy agrees with Yitz; the occasion itself is
sufficiently radical, there is no need to compose a new blessing.
But which blessing should be used? That upon meeting a king, or
that upon seeing a holy man, a tsaddiq? Never before has
there
been an occasion for a Jew to recite a blessing upon meeting a
wise man of another tradition, Zalman says, and therefore a new
blessing is required. Eventually a compromise is reached: Zalman
will recite the traditional blessing in Hebrew, followed by my
Tibetan translation of his newly-composed blessing.
Meeting the Dalai Lama
We finally meet with the Dalai Lama in his fairly modest palace.
I first met him when I was beginning graduate work in 1973. As a
professor of religious studies, part of my job is to meet
religious leaders around the world, and I have been blessed to
meet many -- some saintly, most notably not. None, however,
rises to the Dalai Lama's stature. His humor and warmth are
striking, but it is his mind which impresses me the most. It
goes beyond the usual sort of brilliance which one often
encounters around universities. His mind penetrates with
lightning rapidity; he gets to the heart of the matter more
directly than anyone I have ever met. Perhaps it is the Buddhist
teaching of non-egotism which creates such a flexible type of
intelligence.
After Zalman's blessing, I am the first to speak. In my halting
Tibetan, I great our hosts on behalf of the Jewish people. it is
a moment of fulfillment one rarely attains; for a moment my years
of study of Tibetan language and culture as well as my deep
commitment to Judaism coalesce. I note that this Tibetan-Jewish
dialogue is not really something new, that there are Sanskrit
loan words in the Hebrew Bible, that there have been contacts
between India and Israel ever since the reign of King Solomon,
that King Solomon and the Buddha share legends, that the esoteric
Tibetan system of Kalachakra Tantra ("cycles of time" teachings)
and Jewish messianism may have a common source, that for
millennia Jews have been intermediaries between India and the
West.
Zalman then describes Kabbalah and Jewish esotericism, the inner
dimension of spirituality. His is a crucial role in this
dialogue. Tibetan Buddhism is a tradition especially rich in
esotericism, and Tibetans suspect that a religion which is not
likewise esoteric might be superficial. Much of the overlap
between our traditions lies in esotericism, and the Dalai Lama
said he found Judaism to be much more "sophisticated" than he had
thought -- in no small part a response to Zalman's animated
descriptions of angels, mysteries, divine emanations, and levels
of being.
Next Yitz discusses how the rabbis expanded the scope of Jewish
religious life and conceptions of holiness in response to exile
and the loss of the Temple. He is an excellent balance to
Zalman's esotericism. He never fails to remind the Dalai Lama,
and the rest of us, that while mysticism is indeed a revered part
of Jewish tradition, it most definitely is "a minority opinion."
As Yitz describes the Jewish observance of Shabbat, the Dalai
Lama offers a most insightful comment. Yitz says that Shabbat
harkens back to creation at the same time as it anticipates the
messianic completion of the world. Jews live Shabbat as though
the world were redeemed. The Dalai Lama draws upon his own
meditational tradition of deity yoga visualization to comment,
"You mean that Shabbat is your people's visualization exercise?"
That is precisely what we do: through living "as though," we
participate in the cosmic drama of redemption.
Paul's secularism complements Yitz's Orthodoxy. The Dalai Lama
is intrigued that Jews are able to embrace both secular and
religious members within our family. Paul eloquently articulates
the dilemma of modernity: personal fulfillment is the watchword
of the modern world, whereas communal responsibility is the
hallmark of tradition. Jews are perceived as the first people to
find a balance between the two -- individualism and community --
providing a model for any traditional people confronting the
modern world.
Encounters with Teachers, Monks, Abbots, Nuns
October 26: Fifteen years ago while conducting my
dissertation
research at the Tibetan Library in Dharamsala, I came to know
Alexander Berzin, a Harvard Ph.D. in Oriental Studies who often
serves as the Dalai Lama's interpreter. Of Jewish background,
Alex is now an esteemed teacher of Buddhism. Observing him
during the dialogue, I cannot help but wonder at his thoughts,
what sparks within his Jewish soul are being ignited. After
yesterday's sessions, Alex says to me with a sense of urgency:
"You have got to tell them more about the home. They do not
understand about how the home can be a vehicle for religious
transmission. Unless you teach them about how to observe
religion in the home, the Tibetans will not be able to preserve
their traditions."
Perhaps more than any other people, Tibetans know about the
transformation of the mind, but they do not know so well the
transformation of this reality, which we Jews call the
sanctification of the everyday. While we can and should learn
from them about the former, they need to learn from us about the
latter.
Over lunch with Zalman and a Buddhist monk named George Chernoff,
who despite his name is not Jewish, we hear a story about the
late revered Tibetan teacher, Lama Thubten Yeshe. Lama Yeshe had
many Jewish students and he often said, "If what they learn from
me helps to make them better Jews, then I am most happy, then I
will have served my purpose as a religious teacher." I am
reminded of how Trungpa Rinpoche, the controversial Tibetan
master, several times admonished me to observe Shabbat. Tibetans
do not seek converts; religion for them is not a banner or
allegiance, but a way of improving people, of calming the mind
and cultivating altruism. I cannot help but think that if our
rabbis shared this openness to spirituality, then many fewer
young Jews would seek spiritual edification elsewhere.
During the afternoon we have a rather formal dialogue with the
abbots of leading monasteries. After the formal session, we
invite them back to our guest house for Kabbalat Shabbat and
dinner. It is remarkable to be greeted by one wearing the maroon
monk's robe and a broad smile with a softly-spoken "Shabbat
Shalom."
October 27th: Each morning we have been davening morning
prayers
outside our guest house overlooking the beautiful Kangra Valley,
snow-capped Himalayas to our left, eagles soaring overhead.
After prayers we hold an open house for Western students of
Buddhism, many of them monks or nuns, many Jewish. One nun of
Jewish origin, Thubten Chodron, wants to understand Judaism by
examining me in the rapid-fire, dialectical style of Buddhist
monastic training. She wants to know how Judaism is not just a
set of beliefs and doctrines, but actually a path, a way to
practice. Finally she turns to the G-d idea, asking how I can
justify belief in an omnicient, omnipotent G-d given the
pervasiveness of suffering in a world created by that G-d. Of
course I cannot answer, but I assure her that my inability does
not diminish either my ability to participate in Jewish religious
life nor my access to the inner, experiential dimensions of our
tradition.
In the afternoon we met with a group of "young, educated
Tibetans." These were secularists, some advocating armed
opposition to the Chinese occupation of their country in
contradiction to the Dalai Lama's insistence upon nonviolence.
One Jewish institution which especially interests them are our
Jewish youth camps such as Ramah. Paul had spoken about his
formative experiences at Camp Ramah, now it instilled a sense of
solidarity with his people at an impressionable age. We decide
to invite a Tibetan to observe our summer youth camps to
determine how they could be adapted to the circumstances of
exiled Tibetans.
October 28th: Rodger Kamenetz, a Louisiana writer reporting
on
our dialogue, tells me about an overhead discussion among the
lamas. Some are arguing that this sort of dialogue is not
fruitful, that Buddhists ought to be more concerned about
preserving their traditions than about opening themselves to
others' views. Others argue that such dialogue enriches both
sides, and that Tibetan Buddhists need to learn from Jews and
others. We both reflect how an identical debate could be
overheard in any yeshiva.
In the evening we visit the Tibetan Children's Village. More
than half of the population of the village come from Tibet
proper. Still, mothers make the dangerous and arduous journey
across the Himalayas to deposit a child at the village so it may
be raised within its cultural and religious traditions, a type of
education forbidden by the Chinese rulers of Tibet. The mother
is well aware of the likelihood that she may never see her child
again, but even that sacrifice is not too much if her child may
be raised to be proud of Tibetan heritage.
A very typical encounter: An Indian delegate to the Himalayan
Conference, a government official, asks me if I am from Israel.
"I want to learn something about your people," he says. "All we
read in the newspapers is very slanted. Can you recommend an
authentic book I could read?" His attitude is typical of many
Buddhists and Hindus throughout Asia. Their minds are open; we
need only present our case intelligently and it will be received.
We need to circumvent governments and make contact with
intellectuals and religious leaders directly.
"We are Both Chosen People"
October 29th: The day starts with a visit to Nechung
Monastery,
home of the State Oracle of Tibet. The medium for the Oracle, an
unassuming Buddhist monk, describes his experiences of
mediumship. Zalman compares notes, telling him about the
prophets of ancient Israel, of the visions in the Book of Daniel,
and of the mystical breastplates of the High Priest of the
Temple. The descriptions are remarkably similar.
In the afternoon is our second and concluding session with the
Dalai Lama. Shoshana Edelberg of WUSF radio in Tampa asks him
why he invited Jews for such intensive dialogue. Without missing
a beat, the Dalai Lama replies: "I think we are both chosen
people! We do not have exactly the same idea, but we Tibetans
believe we are chosen by Avalokiteshvara [the embodiment of
Buddhist compassion and the protector deity of Tibet]. You
believe you are chosen by the Creator G-d. So it is almost the
same idea. Another reason: when we became refugees, we knew that
our struggle would not be easy. It will take a long time,
generations. Very often we would refer to the Jewish people, how
they kept their identity and faith despite such hardship and
so much suffering. And when external conditions were ripe, they
were ready to rebuild their nation. So you see, there are many
things to learn from our Jewish brothers and sisters."
Jonathan describes Jewish systems of meditation, many of which
have close parallels in Tibetan tradition. He tells about the
strained relations between the exoteric and esoteric wings of
Judaism, about how most leaders want to bar all but the most
observant from Judaism's mysteries, and about how some want to
"open all the doors" to the esoteric. He prefers a bit more
caution. Next Shabbat, when I speak about our dialogue in the
New Delhi synagogue, the Jews there are amazed to hear that there
is such a thing as Jewish meditation! It is very sad that most
Jews know so little about Jewish meditation and spirituality.
Clearly, we need to open our doors more widely if we are to
retain our spiritual seekers within our fold.
Moshe presents the Dalai Lama with a replica Torah scroll which
Paul had brought from Israel. He describes four levels of
textual interpretation: the literal meaning, the "hinted at"
meaning, the "searched for" meaning, and finally the esoteric
meaning. The relation of commentary to text and the mediation
of the text by the tradition are areas of close overlap between
Tibetan and Jewish traditions.
Blu then tells the Dalai Lama about the Jewish home, the unique
forms of observance and transmission reserved for the family.
Perhaps this is the most fruitful of all exchanges, especially
from a Tibetan point of view. The Dalai Lama's fascination with
our home-centered observances makes me appreciate the singularity
of Jewish traditions.
Finally, Joy speaks about Jewish community institutions -- the
synagogue foremost among them, but also federations, Zionist
alliances, religious schools, and burial societies. Clearly the
Tibetans are intrigued by implications for organizing their own
community, especially since theirs is even more attenuated than
our own. She also presents him with the notebook of letters and
drawings form the children of her synagogue, and the Dalai Lama
reads several of them. It is a touching moment, an especially
deep level of human contact.
Confronting the Issue of Jews Who Become Buddhists
After the presentations, on behalf of us all I raise a painful
issue with the Dalai Lama, that of Jews who join other religions
including Tibetan Buddhism. "Your Holiness," I say, "I must
speak with candor. There remains one issue which pains us. You
have seen our deep sense of family. It is very painful to us,
therefore, when one of our family chooses to leave us. On one
hand, it is clear that Jewish people who adopt the Tibetan path
benefit greatly as individuals. On the other hand, we suffer
from a brain drain on a community level. Many of our finest,
most intelligent, most spiritually-inclined people are leaving
us. I am not asking you a question, nor am I requesting you to
make a statement. But on behalf of my coreligionists, I must
tell you frankly how we feel."
The Dalai Lama is taken aback somewhat by my comments. The
Buddhist attitude is not to seek converts, but at the same time
it makes no distinction among peoples. Anyone who wants the
teachings of the Buddha is entitled to them; religion knows no
national boundary. He explains further the Buddhist belief that
the Buddha offered differing teachings to students of differing
personalities; therefore, no one religious doctrine could satisfy
everyone. His advice, however, is both understanding and sage:
If you want to keep your people in your religion, then you must
open your doors to spirituality. If you have an esoteric
tradition to offer them, then they will not want to leave."
"As a result of our meeting," he continues, "to speak quite
frankly, I developed much more respect for Judaism because I
found there a high level of sophistication. I think it is very
important that you make these teachings available for everyone,
especially intellectual people. Sometimes there is a danger in
too much secrecy. Often qualified people are excluded from the
practice, so I think the best thing is to be flexible. I have
seen many similarities between your tradition and ours. If you
make these teachings available, why would your people want
Buddhist tantra? You have your own tantra! Many of your people
have keen intelligence and very creative minds, and if they are
not personally satisfied with what you offer them, then nobody
could stop them from leaving and taking a new religion. Provide
them with all the materials, all spiritual teachings. If you
have these spiritual values, then there is no reason to fear; if
you have no such values, then there is no reason to hold on.
If you cannot provide spiritual satisfaction to others and at the
same time insist on holding on to them, then that is foolishness.
This is reality." He is entirely right, of course.
Joy beautifully chants the Jewish prayer for scholars, and the
lamas respond by "dedicating the merit" of the prayer to the
welfare of all sentient beings -- a Tibetan "amen." We tearfully
take leave of the Dalai Lama and his entourage, ennobled by the
encounter and stirred by his challenge that we open our doors
widely.
Yitz sums things up in his own way: "As a result of exile, the
Dalai Lama went from being a god to being a man. And he has
grown enormously in the process." Alex thanks us for "making me
proud to be a Jew." The nun Thubten Chodron sees us off, too,
presenting small gifts. The State Oracle had assured us that we
would be safe on the fifteen hour overnight drive back to New
Delhi.
October 31st - New Delhi: On the group's last day in India we
run
into Ram Dass, the Jewish-born Richard Alpert, the Harvard
professor who was fired for LSD research and is now a Hindu guru.
A longtime associate of Zalman, he joins us in our visit to New
Delhi's synagogue and makes the tenth for our minyan. He
also
joins us later for dinner and discusses meditation with Jonathan,
commenting that he would like to refer straying Jews back into
the fold via Jonathan's meditation school. I am struck by the
irony: probably few people in the world have led more Jews away
from Judaism than Ram Dass, yet now he wants to find avenues to
lead some back. I am also struck by how pitiable is his
knowledge of Judaism. After eating, we chant grace, the birkat
ha-mazon. Ram Dass asks: "That was a very pretty tune you sang
after the meal. What was that?" With such a paltry background,
no wonder he left!
November 1st - New Delhi: I stay on for a few days to meet
with
leaders of the city's Tibetan and Jewish communities to report on
our dialogue, which gives me some time to think about the past
two weeks.
For an observant Jew, participation in this sort of dialogue must
raise issues of avodah zarah, a derogatory term meaning
"other
people's worship" something to be avoided by observant Jews. Is
Tibetan Buddhism avodah zarah, or is it another name of G-d?
What is relatively easy for a modern secularist is loaded with
difficulties for someone traditionally religious. There are
ample halakhic authorities, from Saadia Gaon to Maimonides,
who
held quite liberal views regarding other religions. Yet somehow
this liberal thread has receded into the background of Orthodoxy,
and more rigid views have been foregrounded.
Coming out of this dialogue, we have all learned something about
the Tibetan people, their remarkable culture, and their heroic
efforts to maintain that culture in exile. More important,
however, is that all of us now know ourselves differently than we
had before. Of course, we learned a great deal from the other
Jewish delegates; it was a notably learned and articulate group.
But deeper than that, we now have seen ourselves reflected by a
new other -- a Tibetan other -- an other which knows us in
respect and affection.
* * *
Nathan Katz is Professor of Religious Studies at the University
of South Florida. He is the author, with his wife, Ellen S.
Goldberg, of "The Last Jews in India and Burma" (JL101; 1988),
based on their year spent with the Jews of Cochin in South India
and travelling in South Asia. His participation in the
delegation was supported by grants from the Nathan A. Cummings
Foundation, New York, and from the University of South Florida.
The Jerusalem Letter and Jerusalem Letter/Viewpoints are published by the Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs, 13 Tel-Hai St., Jerusalem, Israel; Tel. 972-2-5619281, Fax. 972-2-5619112, Internet: jcpa@netvision.net.il. In U.S.A.: 1515 Locust St., Suite 703, Philadelphia, PA 19102; Tel. (215) 772-0564, Fax. (215) 772-0566. © Copyright. All rights reserved.
|